For the past few years, I have tried to find the best place to store documentation, thoughts, ideas, and more—a tool that truly serves me. In this article, I want to share what I’ve learned and tried.
First, let’s look at what I want to achieve and what is important to me in the process.
While different types of information should probably be stored differently, my main focus here is to save the following categories:
While these things can be stored almost anywhere, I have some requirements for how the tool I use handles the content. Some of these I only noticed as I tried out different options.
These are the tools I tried over the course of several months each. Here are my thoughts about how they held up in relation to what is important for me.
| Tool | Ease of access | Minimalism | Structure and Linking | Sharing | Easy Hosting | Comfort |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MS Word and simple folders (synced) | + PC + Mobile |
(+) Word is a big tool | - | - | + | (+) Not too easy on mobile |
| Mediawiki | + PC (+) Mobile |
- Writing in Mediawiki language is sometimes tricky (the editor is not that nice :D) | + | (+) User setup is not trivial | (+) Maintenance | - Editor is bad and does not work well at all on mobile |
| Obsidian | + PC - Mobile (Native App only works with Obsidian Sync) |
(+) Because the way Obsidian looks and works is customizable, I made it work | + | - Only via hosted Obsidian instance | - Must host own instance | + Super easy and WYSIWYG |
| Jetbrains YouTrack | + PC + Mobile |
- | (+) Not as powerful as other tools | - Not possible | - Must host own instance | - UI not easy for just writing |
| Static MD files with 11ty | + PC + Mobile |
+ Fully customizable to be as minimal as it gets | + Full linking via HTML | + | + | (+) Basically only needs a text editor, no WYSIWYG |
I decided that I will use two tools going forward: Obsidian and Static MD files with 11ty.
Obsidian is unobtrusive in the way I can write in it. It allows easy formatting, is pleasing to the eye, and offers a very flexible layout, so I can experiment with different structures and links without having to think about the “engineering” side of things. It is easily syncable (since it consists of files that can be located in any folder), and I can access it (nearly) everywhere. As the text is formatted using Markdown, I can easily transform my writing into blog posts for my website if I like. The only issue is access from mobile; I will need to figure something out here.
This static site generator is easy to use, and the templating language feels very comfortable for me. My website has used it for several years already (since 2023), and because the content is Markdown-based, I have good integration with Obsidian.
Cheers, Basti